B1 curriculumB1 · Independent communication16 guided steps
B1 · GUIDED LESSON

Integrated task: solve a problem and defend a choice

Explain one familiar practical problem, compare two realistic options against stated constraints, recommend one with two relevant reasons, acknowledge a drawback and propose the next action.

01
Warm-up

Notice the meaning in context

A community group needs a quiet place for an evening meeting, but its usual room is closed. A library room is quiet and free but closes early; a café stays open later but is noisy and costs more. The decision must answer the stated needs, not simply name a favourite place.

02
Lesson objective

What you will be able to do

Explain one familiar practical problem, compare two realistic options against stated constraints, recommend one with two relevant reasons, acknowledge a drawback and propose the next action.

03
Vocabulary focus

Useful language for the task

Start here

une contraintea constraint
deux possibilitéstwo possibilities
un avantagean advantage
un inconvénienta drawback
plus calme quequieter than
préférable àpreferable to

Add these next

je recommande deI recommend
la prochaine étapethe next step
04
Concept

Understand the choice

Start with the practical problem and the constraints that a usable solution must satisfy. In this task, the group needs a quiet place, a low cost and enough time for a serious discussion. A recommendation that ignores those needs is unsupported even if its French is accurate.

Present two realistic options before choosing: reserve a library room or meet in a café. Compare the same relevant criteria for both options—quiet, cost and opening time—so the reader can understand why one option fits better. Do not replace comparison with two unrelated descriptions.

Make the recommendation explicit and support it with two relevant reasons. Je recommande de réserver la bibliothèque parce qu’elle est plus calme et que la salle est gratuite connects the choice directly to the stated constraints. A preference alone—J’aime la bibliothèque—does not solve the problem.

Acknowledge one drawback without cancelling the choice, then propose a next action. Même si la bibliothèque ferme tôt, nous pouvons commencer une heure plus tôt recognizes the limit and preserves the recommendation. Nous devrions réserver la salle aujourd’hui turns the reasoning into a practical step.

05
Examples

See it in complete French

Notre groupe doit organiser une réunion, mais la salle habituelle est fermée.Our group needs to organize a meeting, but the usual room is closed.
Nous avons donc deux possibilités : réserver une salle à la bibliothèque ou nous retrouver dans un café.So we have two possibilities: reserve a room at the library or meet in a café.
La bibliothèque est plus calme que le café.The library is quieter than the café.
Elle est aussi moins chère, car la salle est gratuite.It is also less expensive because the room is free.
En revanche, elle ferme à dix-huit heures.On the other hand, it closes at six o’clock.
Le café reste ouvert plus tard, mais il est souvent bruyant.The café stays open later, but it is often noisy.
Pour une discussion sérieuse, le calme est plus important que l’horaire.For a serious discussion, quiet is more important than the schedule.
À mon avis, la bibliothèque est donc préférable au café.In my opinion, the library is therefore preferable to the café.
Je recommande de réserver cette salle parce que nous pourrons parler sans être dérangés.I recommend reserving this room because we will be able to talk without being disturbed.
Il vaut mieux commencer une heure plus tôt que de chercher un endroit au dernier moment.It is better to start an hour earlier than to look for a place at the last minute.
Même si ce choix oblige certains membres à quitter le travail plus tôt, il répond à notre besoin principal.Even if this choice requires some members to leave work earlier, it meets our main need.
Nous devrions donc choisir la bibliothèque et confirmer la réservation aujourd’hui.We should therefore choose the library and confirm the reservation today.
Si quelqu’un ne peut pas arriver à temps, nous pourrons commencer par un point simple.If someone cannot arrive on time, we can begin with a simple item.
Est-ce que cette solution vous convient, ou préférez-vous le café ?Does this solution suit you, or do you prefer the café?
06
Pattern

Build it step by step

Use one seven-part decision path: 1 exact problem; 2 stated constraints; 3 two realistic options; 4 comparison by the same criteria; 5 clear recommendation; 6 two relevant reasons plus one drawback; 7 next action. Keep every sentence tied to the group’s decision.

Use accurate comparison frames: X est plus ou moins calme que Y; X est aussi pratique que Y; X offre plus ou moins de temps que Y. Use meilleur without plus, and aussi—not autant—before an adjective. Say deux possibilités or deux options when you mean the alternatives available.

Use action frames already studied: Je recommande de choisir X; X est préférable à Y; nous devrions réserver; il vaut mieux commencer tôt que d’attendre. A short invitation such as Est-ce que cette solution vous convient ? can make the recommendation usable in a group without turning it into an exhaustive debate.

07
Comparison

Compare the meanings

La bibliothèque est plus calme que le café compares one relevant quality. Elle offre moins de temps que le café compares available time. Je recommande la bibliothèque parce qu’elle est gratuite et plus calme links two reasons to the choice. Je recommande la bibliothèque parce que j’aime lire states a personal fact that does not answer the meeting constraints.

08
Try it

Make one meaning-and-form decision

Recommend the library for the group meeting. Give quiet and cost as two reasons, acknowledge the early closing time and propose one next action. Keep the reasoning in three connected sentences.

09
Common mistake

Correct the tempting shortcut

Do not write la bibliothèque est plus meilleure or autant pratique que le café; use meilleure or plus pratique, and aussi pratique que. Do not call two available alternatives deux choix when you mean two possibilities. Most importantly, do not list a drawback after the recommendation without explaining how the plan handles it.

10
Real French

Make the speaker’s intention clear

A useful recommendation can remain short. State the problem, compare the same criteria and show the next action. One genuine limit often makes the message more credible: Même si la salle ferme tôt, nous pouvons avancer la réunion. It does not require a long rebuttal or systematic evaluation.

11
Communication connection

Why this matters in tasks

This integrated task practises explaining a familiar problem, comparing workable possibilities and making a reasoned recommendation another person can act on. It is general French practice, not a scored assessment or official exam task.

This lesson teaches general French; it is not official exam material or a CEFR certification.

12
Practice

Controlled and productive practice

Identify the decision path: 1. What is the exact problem when the usual meeting room is closed? 2. Name the three stated constraints: quiet, cost and enough discussion time. 3. What are the two realistic options? 4. Which shared criterion is compared in La bibliothèque est plus calme que le café? 5. In La salle est gratuite, which constraint does the reason answer? 6. What next action appears in Nous devrions confirmer la réservation aujourd’hui? Compare and recommend accurately: 7. Complete: La bibliothèque est ___ calme que le café. 8. Complete: Le café offre ___ de temps que la bibliothèque. 9. Complete an equal comparison: Le café est ___ facile d’accès que la bibliothèque. 10. Correct: La bibliothèque est plus meilleure pour une discussion. 11. State a clear recommendation with Je recommande de… 12. Add two reasons with parce que… et que… Build the complete response: 13. Explain the closed-room problem, constraints and two possibilities. 14. Compare quiet, cost and opening time, then choose the library with two reasons. 15. Acknowledge its early closing, adapt the plan and state today’s next action. Correct and explain: 16. Nous avons deux choix : la bibliothèque ou le café, when you mean two available alternatives. 17. La bibliothèque est autant pratique que le café. 18. Je recommande la bibliothèque parce que j’aime les livres, although the stated needs are quiet, cost and time.

13
Answer explanations

Correct the reasoning, not only the form

Try it corrections: Je recommande de réserver la salle de la bibliothèque parce qu’elle est plus calme et gratuite. Même si elle ferme à dix-huit heures, nous pouvons commencer une heure plus tôt. Nous devrions donc confirmer la réservation aujourd’hui. The two reasons answer quiet and cost; the timing adjustment manages the drawback; the final sentence names the next action.

Practice 1–6 decision parts: 1. The group needs a replacement place for its meeting. 2. The place should be quiet, inexpensive and available long enough for the discussion. 3. Reserve a library room or meet in a café. 4. Quiet is the shared criterion. 5. Cost: a free room respects the low-cost constraint. 6. Confirm the reservation today; the reasoning ends with an action rather than a preference alone.

Practice 7–12 comparisons and recommendation: 7. La bibliothèque est plus calme que le café. 8. Le café offre plus de temps que la bibliothèque. 9. Le café est aussi facile d’accès que la bibliothèque. Aussi modifies the adjective phrase. 10. La bibliothèque est meilleure pour une discussion, or La bibliothèque est plus pratique pour une discussion. Do not combine plus with meilleur. 11. Je recommande de réserver la bibliothèque. 12. Je recommande la bibliothèque parce qu’elle est plus calme et que la salle est gratuite. Both reasons answer stated constraints.

Practice 13–15 connected model: 13. Notre groupe doit organiser une réunion, mais la salle habituelle est fermée. Nous avons besoin d’un endroit calme, peu coûteux et disponible assez longtemps. Nous avons deux possibilités : la bibliothèque ou un café. 14. La bibliothèque est plus calme et gratuite, tandis que le café reste ouvert plus tard. Je recommande donc la bibliothèque parce qu’elle permet une discussion sérieuse et respecte notre budget. 15. Même si elle ferme tôt, nous pouvons commencer à dix-sept heures. Nous devrions confirmer la réservation aujourd’hui. The limit changes the schedule but does not cancel the choice.

Corrections 16–18: 16. Nous avons deux possibilités : la bibliothèque ou le café. Possibilités names the alternatives available; choosing comes afterwards. 17. La bibliothèque est aussi pratique que le café. Aussi modifies the adjective pratique; autant modifies a verb or a quantity. 18. Je recommande la bibliothèque parce qu’elle est plus calme et gratuite. These reasons address the actual meeting constraints; liking books does not explain why the place solves the problem.

14
Mini challenge

Produce connected French

Write and record a seven-to-nine-sentence recommendation for a familiar group problem. State the problem and constraints, present exactly two realistic options, compare the same criteria, recommend one with two relevant reasons, acknowledge one drawback and propose the next action. Ask one short question inviting the group’s view, then check that every reason supports the final choice.

15
Review

Keep the meaning-and-form decision

Solve the stated problem rather than naming a favourite: identify the constraints, compare two realistic options by the same criteria, recommend one with two relevant reasons, manage one drawback and finish with a next action.

16
Next lesson

Review the complete B1 sequence

You have reached the end of the complete reviewed 18-lesson B1 sequence. Revisit a lesson, retry its practice and explain the correction before moving into later-level work.

NEXT STEP

B1 published sequence complete

Review the complete published sequence and revisit its examples, corrections and integrated task to target the skills that still need work.

Course map