Build a structured argument
Write and revise a 220–280-word response on a familiar public issue with a qualified position, two distinct reasons, relevant support, a fair counterargument and a conclusion that follows from the reasoning.
01Warm-upNotice the function and sentence shape
+
Notice the function and sentence shape
A public library is considering longer Saturday opening hours. Compare Il faut absolument ouvrir plus longtemps, car ce serait mieux with a position that names a reason, uses the supplied facts and acknowledges the added cost. Which version gives a reader something to evaluate?
02Lesson objectiveWhat you will be able to do
+
What you will be able to do
Write and revise a 220–280-word response on a familiar public issue with a qualified position, two distinct reasons, relevant support, a fair counterargument and a conclusion that follows from the reasoning.
03Vocabulary focusUseful sentence-control language
+
Useful sentence-control language
Start here
04ConceptUnderstand the form decision
+
Understand the form decision
A structured argument is a logical chain, not a universal skeleton. Frame the issue and state a qualified position; develop one reason with relevant evidence or an example and explain the connection; add a genuinely distinct reason; represent a counterargument fairly, concede what is valid and respond; then draw a conclusion without introducing a new major reason.
Keep one main job per paragraph, but let the reasoning determine the organization. A claim needs support, and evidence needs an explanation of how it supports the claim. In the library scenario, Some people work or study on weekdays is an observation supplied by the task; extending the hours will solve every access problem is an unsupported prediction.
Name the relationship before choosing a connector. En effet can introduce an explanation, par exemple a concrete illustration, certes a concession and cependant a contrast or response. Connectors guide the reader; they cannot repair an irrelevant reason or create a relationship that the ideas do not contain.
05ExamplesSee each form in complete French
+
See each form in complete French
06PatternBuild it step by step
+
Build it step by step
Position: frame the issue and make a proportionate claim, for example La bibliothèque devrait tester une ouverture prolongée le samedi pendant trois mois. Avoid presenting a recommendation as a certainty about every user.
Development: reason → evidence or example → explanation. Add a second reason that contributes a different consideration. Distinguish a supplied fact or observation from your interpretation, opinion or prediction, and do not invent statistics.
Counterargument and conclusion: state the strongest relevant objection fairly; use a concession to accept its valid part; respond with a limit, condition or alternative. Conclude from the balance already established, such as recommending a pilot and review, rather than adding a surprise argument.
07ComparisonCompare the meanings
+
Compare the meanings
D’abord and premièrement can mark a first reason. En effet explains why a claim is plausible, whereas par exemple illustrates it. Certes, l’ouverture prolongée aurait un coût supplémentaire concedes a real objection; cependant, un projet pilote permettrait d’évaluer la fréquentation responds without denying the cost. En conclusion or en fin de compte should gather the result of the reasoning, not merely repeat the opening.
08Try itMake one meaning-and-form decision
+
Make one meaning-and-form decision
Using only these supplied facts — some residents work or study on weekdays, longer hours cost more, and a three-month pilot is possible — write a qualified position followed by one reason, one supporting fact and an explanation of their relationship.
09Common mistakeAvoid a mechanical order rule
+
Avoid a mechanical order rule
Do not pour ideas into a memorized five-paragraph frame, list several near-identical reasons, or use connectors as decoration. A striking example does not replace the explanation that links evidence to the claim. Represent the counterargument accurately, preserve the limits of supplied facts and qualify predictions; never invent a percentage to make the position sound authoritative.
10Real FrenchKeep the relationship clear
+
Keep the relationship clear
Strong argumentation can be firm and nuanced at the same time. Certes… cependant does not mean abandoning a position: it shows that the writer has evaluated a constraint before responding. A short pilot, explicit criteria and a later review can support a proportionate recommendation when the available evidence is limited.
11Communication connectionWhy this matters in tasks
+
Why this matters in tasks
Reasoned public writing lets a reader distinguish the position, reasons, support, limitation and response. This is supported B2-level practice aligned with general CEFR descriptors; it is not a standardized assessment template, a scoring promise or proof of complete B2 mastery.
This lesson teaches general French; it is not official exam material or a CEFR certification.
12PracticeControlled and productive practice
+
Controlled and productive practice
Identify the argument roles: 1. What is the writer’s position? 2. Which two reasons are genuinely distinct? 3. Which statement is a supplied fact, and which is a prediction? 4. What makes a counterargument fair rather than distorted? 5. What should a concession accept before the writer responds? 6. Why must the conclusion follow from the developed reasons? Choose and connect: 7. Qualify the absolute La mesure aidera tout le monde. 8. Choose the reason most relevant to Saturday library hours. 9. Add one example and explain its relevance. 10. Choose en effet for an explanation and par exemple for an illustration. 11. Join the added-cost objection and the pilot response with Certes… cependant. 12. Express a reasoned result with donc or par conséquent. Build the argument: 13. Reorder these elements into a logical chain: supplied observation; position; explanation; reason. 14. Build one paragraph from the supplied fact that some residents work or study on weekdays. 15. Add a second argument that is distinct from weekday availability. Correct and explain: 16. This paragraph has many connectors but weak logic: Premièrement, la bibliothèque est utile. En effet, j’aime lire. Par conséquent, elle doit ouvrir toute la nuit. 17. Tous les habitants veulent cette mesure et 93 % viendront chaque samedi. 18. En conclusion, les horaires doivent changer. De plus, la ville devrait construire une nouvelle bibliothèque.
13Answer explanationsCorrect the reasoning and form
+
Correct the reasoning and form
Try it corrections: La bibliothèque devrait tester une ouverture prolongée le samedi pendant trois mois. En effet, certains habitants travaillent ou étudient en semaine; des horaires élargis leur offriraient donc un accès supplémentaire. This separates the recommendation from the supplied observation and makes the reasoning visible without claiming that every resident would benefit.
Practice 1–6 roles: 1. The qualified recommendation the writer asks the reader to accept. 2. Two reasons that add different considerations rather than restating one another. 3. A supplied observation is presented as given; a prediction is a reasoned but uncertain consequence. 4. It states a relevant objection in a form its supporters could recognize. 5. The valid part of the objection. 6. A conclusion should report the result of the reasoning instead of adding unsupported material.
Practice 7–12 connections: 7. La mesure pourrait améliorer l’accès de certains habitants. 8. Certains habitants travaillent ou étudient en semaine, so a Saturday option can address a stated access constraint. 9. Par exemple, une personne occupée du lundi au vendredi disposerait d’un autre créneau; the example illustrates the weekday-access reason. 10. En effet explains a claim; par exemple supplies an instance. 11. Certes, l’ouverture prolongée aurait un coût supplémentaire; cependant, un projet pilote de trois mois permettrait d’évaluer la fréquentation avant une décision durable. 12. La mesure peut être testée et évaluée; par conséquent, une phase pilote constitue une réponse proportionnée.
Practice 13–15 construction: 13. Position → reason → supplied observation → explanation. 14. Une ouverture prolongée améliorerait l’accès de certains usagers. En effet, des habitants travaillent ou étudient en semaine; un créneau le samedi leur donnerait une possibilité supplémentaire. 15. A distinct second argument could concern evaluation: a three-month pilot would produce attendance information before a permanent commitment. It does not simply repeat availability.
Corrections 16–18: 16. Connectors do not establish that liking reading justifies all-night opening. Replace it with a relevant claim-support-explanation chain and a proportionate recommendation. 17. The universal claim and percentage are unsupported; write Certains habitants pourraient utiliser ces horaires, puis rely only on supplied information. 18. Remove the new construction proposal. A valid ending is En conclusion, une ouverture prolongée pourrait être testée pendant trois mois, puis évaluée à partir de la fréquentation et du coût.
14Mini challengeWrite and record a connected message
+
Write and record a connected message
Write and record a response of 220–280 words on whether the library should extend Saturday opening hours. Use only these supplied facts: some people work or study on weekdays; added hours have a cost; a three-month pilot is possible; attendance can be reviewed. State a qualified position, develop two distinct reasons with support and explanation, present a fair counterargument, concede its valid part, respond, and draw a conclusion with no new major reason.
15ReviewKeep the function-and-form decision
+
Keep the function-and-form decision
Build a visible chain from qualified position to distinct reasons, relevant support and explanation. Treat the strongest counterargument fairly, concede what is valid, respond proportionately and conclude from the reasoning. Choose connectors after identifying the relationship, and never strengthen limited evidence into certainty.
16Next lessonContinue the B2 foundations
+
Continue the B2 foundations
Continue to b2/16-synthesis-and-paraphrase: Synthesis and paraphrase. It is the next B2 foundation lesson.